Should You Repair or Replace Your Roof?

It's one of the most common roofing questions homeowners ask — especially when facing a minor leak or isolated shingle damage.

But here's the truth:
In many cases, repairing an aging roof is like slapping duct tape on a sinking boat — it only delays the inevitable.

1. Roof Repairs Are Temporary Fixes

Repair jobs address the symptom — not the system.

You might fix:

• A missing shingle
• A flashing leak
• An isolated soft spot

But those patches rarely address:

• Overall roof age
• Widespread wear
• Failing underlayment

Repairs often cost $300–$1,200 each, and many homeowners end up doing multiple repairs within a couple years — spending as much as they would have on a full replacement.

2. Repairs Don't Extend Your Roof's Lifespan

If your roof is:

• 15+ years old
• Showing curling, cracking, or bald shingles
• Leaking in multiple spots

…a repair won't reset the clock. You're still going to need a full replacement soon — especially with Maryland's intense seasons.

Replacing now saves you:

• Multiple service calls
• Repeat disruption
• Risk of emergency damage

3. Only Full Replacements Come With Warranties That Matter

Most roofers don't warranty repairs beyond a year (if at all).
At Allied, our full roof replacements come with:

• A lifetime labor warranty
• Coverage that matches the shingle manufacturer
• A documented installation system

We don't patch. We replace — the right way — and guarantee it for life.

4. Patching Can Void Insurance or Warranty Claims

If you patch a problem spot but leave your roof's broader issues unaddressed, your insurance provider might deny future claims due to "failure to maintain."

And if your shingles still had a material warranty, unauthorized patching can sometimes void that coverage entirely.

5. A New Roof Adds More Than Protection — It Adds Value

Besides peace of mind, full replacements:

• Improve curb appeal instantly
• Boost energy efficiency
• Increase resale value
• Make your home easier to insure

Home buyers and real estate agents in Maryland counties like Howard, Montgomery, and Baltimore often prioritize homes with recent roof replacements — and even use them as listing highlights.

Why Allied Recommends Full Replacement First

We don't do repairs — and here's why:

• They rarely solve the root problem
• They don't offer long-term protection
• They leave homeowners vulnerable to repeat issues

Instead, we focus on complete, warrantied replacements — like our $3,999 Roof Replacement Offer, which includes:

• Up to 14 squares of architectural shingles
• Full tear-off of one layer
• Underlayment, drip edge, and ice & water shield
• Lifetime labor warranty
• Zero deposit required

Still Debating? We'll Give You Honest Advice

Our team doesn't pressure you. We assess your roof, show you exactly what's going on, and explain why a full replacement may be the smarter move — even if it's a little sooner than you planned.

Get Peace of Mind — Not Patchwork

Request your free estimate today.
No deposit. No patch jobs. Just honest answers and premium roof replacements built to last.